Essence gel eyeliner update

I am sorry to report a certain fact about Essence gel eyeliners...I got a silver one from my sister and it unfortunately dried up within weeks. Recently, my sister has noticed that the same happened with her black one. And now I have heard the same thing from yet another friend.

I can still use my gel eyeliner with a really stiff brush, but it is quite difficult to apply. So, no matter how cheap they are to buy, you should either use it up quickly or get a Catrice one...